I guess what I really want is to have my cake and eat it too... Ideally I'd like to be free of both the habit AND the battle to be free of the habit. ie: to be a 'normal' person...
Despite surviving this event without pain or regret, I made a point of not touching any alcohol for the next several days. Then I went through a few very stressful days at work, got tired of worrying about drinking, and had a few (but just a few - I didn't find them very enjoyable and stopped).
I know it's very possible moderating may not be the long term solution for me. I also know, just as the old addage goes "Rome wasn't built in a day", a 40 year habit is not undone by snapping my fingers and declaring it so. Perhaps I'm going about it by what some would consider the hard way, but I just feel that swearing off it forever is the surest way to guarantee I never achieve complete abstention. I feel that unlearning drinking as a habit and cutting it out one day at a time is the saner approach for me at this time. Maybe I'll eventually make it to complete abstention or maybe I won't, but the pressure of feeling I have to seems to trip me up at the start. Just drinking a lot less in the future than I have in the past would already be a big victory. I must adjust my outlook to take every situation and event for what it is, not for the drinking opportunity it could be. (Is that the psychic shift then?)
I finally let my wife in on what I'm doing. I told her I feel that I need to quit drinking as I often fail at moderating. I was sure she'd back me up 200% on that and then some. (Her career is centered on the treatment of people facing debilitating, disfiguring, and terminal illnesses related to substance abuse, and we recently lost a very close family member to exactly that.) This is perhaps why it took me so long - I felt that once I announced this to her I'd have her on me like a hawk for ever more. Her reaction surprised me: "You? no you don't drink too much, not around me at least, though I don't see how much you have when I'm not here..." She feels I should just focus on limiting myself to a maximum of 3 on days where I drink. I guess she has no idea how constraining that limit can seem to us drinkers; sometimes 3 would do just fine, but often it would be an unwelcome limitation, and I’d rather go without altogether than constrain myself to it.
Don’t get me wrong, everyone is different and I value and consider each of your views and experiences very seriously. Each must make their own way but there is something to learn from everything, and everyone. Thanks very much (again) for your insight and wisdom. I’ll keep checking in – however I may be coming across I am serious about persevering.