K, I wanted to be able to give this the time for a thoughtful response. The part where you said you don't hear about people on this site who moderate rather than stop altogether. I find it a puzzling issue as well because I'm navigating these decisions myself and, well, I am no expert!
I have't really spoken much about my goals in terms of alcohol because I am in generally hyper worried about what people think, so even on an anonymous drinking support site I fear there will be the people who think "she's kidding herself" or "she's going to slip back into old habits". But it's been 5 weeks since I binged (which included a trip with alcohol included), and I haven't stopped altogether.
I think it really depends on your history, your personality, where you're coming from. I'm working hard on changing my thought patterns and behavioural responses and learning not to let my feelings guide me. So I've been consciously deciding beforehand when I will allow myself to have a drink (not in situations where I might feel vulnerable) and only when I'm not doing it to hide something else. Moderating for me involves a LOT of pre-planning and guideline setting (and telling my husband my plans). I've set a goal to stay under the low risk guidelines for Canada and so far it has been working. If you ask me, I'd say it is possible. But I really think it depends on so many different factors. Your family history, your own history, the severity of your drinking, the reasons for your drinking, your experience with positive coping, the amount of "tools" in your "toolbox"....
I kind of feel like I am "growing up again" and with that comes a total overhaul on everything. I'm finding that now that I am challenging some of the underlying issues I understand more why I used to have to drown my feelings and now I can make different choices.
I dunno. those are just my thoughts. My little positive victory for today was a self-esteem plummeting remark from a close family member that I tried really hard not to let erode all the work I've been doing on being nice to myself. And I chose not to buy that bottle of wine after work because I knew it would just contribute to the erosion. I woke up feeling happy and strong :)